McClintock Web Culbertsons

65. SAMUEL⁵ MCFATE (Samuel⁴ McFate, Jane³, John², Unknown¹); born circa 1837; married ELIZA FIELD of Ontario, Canada. Samuel was a Civil War veteran, 142d Pennysylvania infantry, wounded at Fredericksburg.¹¹¹¹

Child of Samuel and Eliza (Field) McFate:

	166	i.	Samuel⁶ McFate.

66. JANE⁵ H. MCFATE (Samuel⁴ McFate, Jane³, John², Unknown¹); born March 1839 in Pennsylvania; married JOSEPH MCCLINTOCK, born 28 January 1810 near Venice, Washington County Pennsylvania; died 7 March 1879 in Chase City, Virginia. There is a picture of Jane (McFate) McClintock with two of her grandsons in the “Life Story of Joseph and Jane (McFate) McClintock.”¹¹¹²

I have not been able to place this Joseph McClintock with our Oil Creek McClintocks. Reverend Joseph McClintock, an ordained Presbyterian minister, was a son of William McClintock, born circa 1760; died 12 January 1826, and Hannah [—?—] McClintock, born circa 1767; died 11 January 1826 (one day before Joseph died).¹¹¹³ Possibly Joseph had another wife, Maria, as reported in Howard Verschell’s 14 June 1997 email: “Jane McFate was apparently not Joseph’s first wife; Edwin found while tracing his grandfather’s ministry, in a cemetery near Montville, Pennsylvania, two gravestones, the larger of which is inscribed: In Memory of Maria, Consort of Rev. Joseph McClintock, Who departed this life April 17, 1834, In the 30th Year of her age.” The smaller stone was that of an infant son. I have not been able to associate Joseph or his parents, William and Hannah McClintock, with our McClintock line.

According to Howard Verschell (see Acknowledgements) , William McClintock came to Muskinghum County, Ohio, in circa 1815, from Washington County, Pennsylvania. Both William and wife Hannah are buried in Shannon Baptist Cemetery, near Frazyburgh (Muskinghum County), Ohio, and their stones (moved to Woodland Cemetery, Hutchison plot, Xenia, Ohio) are the source for their death dates. Howard Verschell lists, in addition to Joseph, six other children of William of Hannah McClintock: (1) James McClintock, married 1827; (2) Robert McClintock; (3) William McClintock, married 1828; (4) Alexander McClintock; (5) Elizabeth McClintock, born circa 1796; died 1863, did not marry; (6) Hannah McClintock, born circa 1805; died 25 August 1828.

“The Life Story of Joseph and Jane (McFate) McClintock” reports that Joseph studied theology at Cannonsburg Seminary, Pennsylvania, and was licensed by Chartiers Presbytery [present–day Allegheny County?] in 1843. His charges were mainly in Ohio and Pennsylvania, including Utica and Cooperstown in Venango County. Many of his sermons had the theme of retaining the Seceder insistence of closed communion. Reverend McClintock was one of the founders of Westminster College (New Wilmington, Lawrence County, Pennsylvania), and in 1855 was elected President of the Board of Trustees of Westminster College. For some time at least, Joseph, Jane and family made their home in the hamlet of Worth, Lackawannock Township, Mercer County, Pennsylvania. Excerpts from Joseph McClintock’s diary are included in his biography. Below are entries made during a visit to the Oil Creek area in 1863:¹¹¹⁴

June 30th 1863. 7. oclock A. M. Started in co. with Professor Patterson to Oildom, having Barry [his horse] to P’s buggy. Had dinner at Hendersonville – Went through Franklin – called for lodging at the 2d hotel we found in Oil City, but it was a wretchedly mean dirty concern – No bag for Barry – Oats 90 cents per lb. hay $30 per ton and none to be had at that – Walked up to the bridge on oil creek astonished at the improvements made within a year – heard fine music on 2 violins & 1 accordion – slept on a damp suffocating room – Got up at 5 1/2 in the morning of 31st for some thing else – Went up to Rouseville – waited 2 hours to see a man – Drove up to John McFate’s place (Mr. Curtins) [someone had pencilled in that John McFate “died 17 May 1868”] reached there at 12 ocl. Went to the oil well at the River then to Mr. Shaws, then to Mrs. McFates [someone had pencilled in "Jane’s mother"]. Put up for all night. Let Barry into pasture til 9 oclock, then tied him to a limb of an apple tree til morning. Started to Humbolt Oil works, next to Rouseville. Had dinner there. Came up to Robert McFates [someone had pencilled in “prob. Jane’s brother”] – staid over night. July 3d Started to the oil well at Walnut Bend – saw some men there, made a little arrangement for farther correspondence about the oilwell – Came up and had dinner at Mr. Shaws. Started home – reached Mercer É. . . .

There was a Joseph McClintock mentioned in an 1860 land deed¹¹¹⁵ reporting James Story, Joseph McClintock, and Joseph Patterson leasing land in Cornplanter Township, Venango County, Pennsylvania, from Samuel Tolls for $1500 dollars. This Joseph McClintock was probably Joseph McClintock, husband of Jane McFate.

In 1850, Joseph, apparently not married, was living with a George and Martha Leslie and the Leslie children in Shenango Township, Lawrence County, Pennsylvania, where Joseph was enumerated as an associate preacher. In 1870 Joseph, Jane and family were in Lackawannock Township, (Worth Post office) Mercer County, Pennsylvania, where Joseph was listed as a minister. By 1880, Joseph had died, and Jane and family were in Blue Stone, Mecklenburg County, Virginia—no occupations listed for Jane or children. By 1900, Jane and children Joseph and Lillian were in Monmouth, Warren County, Illinois.¹¹¹⁶

Children of Joseph and Jane (McFate) McClintock:¹¹¹⁷

167	i.	Maria⁶ Reed McClintock; born 17 July 1863 in Mercer County, Pennsylvania; married [—?—] Johnston.¹¹¹⁸
168	ii.	Joseph McClintock; born 16 July 1866 in Pennsylvania; died 1910 in Kirkwood, Warren County, Illinois. In 1900, Joseph was living with his mother and sister Lillian in Monmouth, Warren County, Illinois, where Joseph was enumerated as a carpenter. Joseph probably did not marry.
169	iii.	Thaddeus S. McClintock; born circa 1867; married Anna J. [—?—]; born circa 1872 in Pennsylvania. In 1930, the family was living in Pittsburgh, Ward 19, Allegheny County, Pennsylvania (page 11A), where Thaddeus was listed as an engineer in a power house. Child known from the 1930 federal census: (1) Edward S. McClintock, born circa 1900.
170	iv.	Edwin McClintock; born 1 July 1868 in Worth, Lackawannock Township, Mercer County, Pennsylvania; died 18 November 1948 in Indiana County, Pennsylvania; married Jennie Pearly Hutchinson., born 5 January 1877 in Ohio; died 19 November 1948 (apparently one day after her husband died) in Indiana County, Pennsylvania. Edwin McClintock was the author of “The Life Story of Joseph and Jane (McFate) McClintock.”. In 1900. Edwin was listed as a lodger and a student in the household of a Joseph Denk and family in Lancaster Township, Wells County, Indiana (page 9B). In 1910, Joseph, and family were living in Plain Grove Township, Lawrence County, Pennsylvania, where Edwin was listed as a minister of a United Presbyterian Church (census page 6B). In 1920, the family had moved to West Middlesex Township, Mercer County, Pennsylvania, where Edwin was still a minister in the UP Church (census page 4B). By 1930, the family was in Lower Burrell Township, Westmoreland County, Pennsylavania (page 3B), where Edwin was enumerated as a clergyman, Congregational. Children of Edwin and Jennie known from the 1910, 1920 and 1930 federal; censuses: (a) Edwin Howard McClintock, born circa 1907 in Pennsylvania (b) William Lawrence McClintock, born circa 1908 in Pennsylvania (c) Kathryn Jane McClintock, born circa 1912 in Pennsylvania. ;
171	v.	Lillian McClintock; born 29 September 1872 in Pennsylvania; died 20 October 1931; buried in Center Grove Cemetery, Kirkwood, Warren County, Illinois; married 26 December 1900 in Warren County, Illinois, Willis Edwin Lanphere, born 3 June 1876 in Warren County, Illinois; died 8 June 1932; buried in Center Grove Cemetery, Kirkwood, Illinois. They had one child, Paul Lanphere.¹¹¹⁹ He died young. 1910 federal census reports Lillian had one child, deceased by 1910. Willis and Lillian lived in Tompkins, Warren County, Illinois in 1910 (census page 2B), 1920 (page 14B) and 1930 (page 6B), where Willis was enumerated as a farmer.

72. WASHINGTON⁵ CULBERTSOM (Patrick⁴, Francis³, John², Unknown¹); born February 1844 in Pennsylvania; died 1917; married ALMIRA (also Elmina) LOWRIE,¹¹²⁰ born April 1846 in Pennsylvania.

The family lived in Kingsville, Ohio in 1880, 1900 and 1910; when Washington was listed as a farmer—by 1910, Washington and Almira were living with their married daughter Gertrude Gee in Kingsville. By 1920, Washington had died, and Elmina, widow, was living with her daughter Gertrude Gee and her family in Kingsville, Ohio.¹¹²¹.

Children of Washington and Elmina (Lowrie) Culbertson (all born in Ohio):

+	172	i.	Frederick⁶ Lewis Culbertson; born 1867; married Susan Henry.
	173	ii.	Elizabeth Culbertson; born 1869; died 1869.
+	174	iii.	Francis Orren Culbertson; born 1870; married Florence Wiggans.
	175	iv.	Cora Amelia Culbertson; born August 1873 in Pennsylvania; married (first) in 1903 Louis Shade; died 1912; married (second) in 1918, John Dean; died 1918; married (third) in 1922, E. C. Towne.
+	176	v.	Gertrude Bell Culbertson; born 1879; married Schon Gee.

76. MARY⁵ ELIZABETH CULBERTSON (Robert⁴, Francis³, John², Unknown¹); born 14 June 1845 in Pennsylvania; died 16 December 1925 in Willis, Washtenaw County, Michigan; buried in Udell Cemetery, Ypsilanti, Michigan; married 5 July 1866 in Meadville, Pennsylvania, ANZLOW (ALONZO?) SNODGRASS; born 18 May 1841 in Venango County, Pennsylvania; died 24 December 1904 in Detroit, Wayne County, Michigan; buried in Udell Cemetery. Anzlow’s parents were Benjamin and Mary (Salgiver) Snodgrass.¹¹²²

In 1880, "Angello" (sic = Anzlow), Mary, and children Robert and James were living in Ypsilanti, Washtenaw County, Michigan (page 396), where Anzlow was enumerated as a laborer. In 1900, Anzlow, Mary, and son James were living in Detroit, Michigan, where Anzlow was enumerated as a brakeman on the railroad, and James as a laborer. They were next door to Anzlow and Mary’s son Robert.¹¹²³ By 1910, Anzlow had died, and Mary (enumerated as Jane E.) and son James, a farm laborer, were in Augusta, Washtenaw County, Michigan (page 8A). Mary and son James were still in Augusta, Michigan, in 1920 (page 3B).

Children of Alonzo and Mary Culbertson Snodgrass:

	177	i.	Robert⁶ Alexander Snodgrass; born 18 August 1867 in President Township, Venango County; died 25 September 1934; married Emily A. Neltner, born December 1871 in Michigan. The family lived in Detroit, Michigan, where Robert was enumerated as a grocery clerk in 1900 (when living next to Robert's parents) and as a baggageman for the railroad in 1910, 1920 and 1930.¹¹²⁴ Also in the family in 1900 was Laura Neltner, Emily's sister. Robert and Emily were the grandparents of Marilyn Snodgrass (Farmington Hills, Michigan), who provided valuable information on the Culbertsons, including the Snodgrasses. Children known from the federal censuses (all born in Michigan): (a) Harry N. Snodgrass, born January 1891; married Mildred Vannorman; born circa 1898 in Michigan. In 1930 Harry and Mildred were living with Mildred parents, Charles and Marion Vannorman, in Detroit, Michigan (page 42A), where Harry was enumerated as "electrical motor truck." Child known from the 1930 federal census: (i) Marilynn V. Snodgrass. (b) Howard C. Snodgrass, born October 1899. (c) Harold J. Snodgrass, born circa 1914.
	178	ii.	James Anzlow Snodgrass; born 11 February 1869 in Washtenaw County, Michigan; died 10 March 1933. In 1900, 1910 and 1920, James, single, was living in Augusta, Washtenaw County, Michigan, with his mother; James was listed as a laborer in 1900 and 1910 and as a laborer on public roads in 1920. James at age 60, married circa 1926 Maude [—?—]; born circa 1866 in Ohio. In 1930, they were in Augusta, Michigan, where James was listed as a laborer, architect. Also living with James and Maude in 1930 was Claude Wooland, born circa 1922 in Michigan; he was enumerated as a Ward.

77. JAMES⁵ R. CULBERTSON (Robert⁴, Francis³, John², Unknown¹); born circa 1843;¹¹²⁵ died December 1887;¹¹²⁶ married 20 October 1873 ELIZABETH WHITEHILL (or Whitehall). Marriage announcement from the Oil City Weekly Times, 24 October 1873:¹¹²⁷ “James R. Culbertson of Oleopolis [Cornplanter Township ] to Lizzie J. Whitehall of South Oil City on 20 October in Oil City at the residence of the bride’s father on 6th Street.”

Child of James R. and Elizabeth (Whitehill/Whitehall) Culbertson:

	179	i.	Charles⁶ C. Culbertson; born 1880; died 1918.

A GenServ report¹¹²⁸ has a James R. Culbertson, born 24 March 1868 marrying 14 September 1893 Maude Milligan, born 24 June 1872; she was a daughter of Robert Milligan. The GenServ report does not mention locations. The same report has a Hugh McClintock marrying a Nellie Milligan, born 13 January 1785. She was a daughter of John and Mary (Adams) Milligan.

78. LOUISA⁵ A. CULBERTSON (Robert⁴, Francis³, John², Unknown¹); born November 1848; married WILLIAM WILLINGS, born circa 1840. He was a son of Richard and probably Maria [—?—] Willings, born circa 1806,¹¹²⁹ of Venango County, Pennsylvania.¹¹³⁰

In 1870, the family was enumerated in Ypsilanti Township, Washtenaw County, Michigan, and were living near Louisa’s sisters Mary (Snodgrass) (#76) and Isabella (Mason). In 1880, Louisa’s mother, Mary Carey Culbertson, was living with Louisa, William and family. In 1900, William and Louisa were still in Augusta Township, Washtenaw County, Michigan. By 1910, William had died, and Louisa, widow, mother-in-law, was living with her married daughter Cora M. Lohe in Augusta Township, Washtenaw, Michigan. In 1920, Louisa was living with her married daughter Laura L. Adair in Romulus Township, Wayne County, Michigan.¹¹³¹

Children of William and Louisa (Culbertson) Willings:¹¹³²

	180	i.	Laura⁶ Willings; born circa 1867 in Michigan; married Thomas Adair; born circa 1861 in Michigan. Thomas and Laura lived in Romulus Township, Wayne County, Michigan, where Thomas was listed as a rural mail carrier in 1910 (page 4B), as a farmer in 1920 (page 2B) and with no occupation listed in 1930 (page 2A). Apparently Thomas and Laura did not have children. Also in the family in 1920 was Laura's mother, Louisa Willings.
	NN	ii.	Cora Willings; born circa 1880 in Michigan; married Ernest E. Lohe; born circa 1879 in Michigan. In 1910 Ernest, Cora and daughter Metha were living in Romulus Township, Wayne County, Michigan (page 6A), where Thomas was a farmer. Also in the family in 1910 was Cora's mother, Louisa Willings. Child known from the 1910 federal census: Metha Lohe, born circa 1901 in Michigan.

80. THOMAS⁵ ALEXANDER ANDERSON (Elizabeth⁴, Francis³, John², Unknown¹); born 1845 in Pennsylvania; died 1898; married 1866 HARRIET LOUISA HARTSHORN, born 1845 in Pennsylvania; died 1925. This information is from Culbertson (1923), page 425, who states Thomas was a Civil War veteran: “wounded in the leg from which he never fully recovered.” In 1870, Thomas, Louisa and children Mabel and Anna were living in Oil City, Venango County, Pennsylvania (page 209), where Thomas was listed as a drug store merchant.

Children of Thomas and Harriet (Hartshorn) Anderson:¹¹³³

181	i.	Mabel⁶ Duiera Anderson; born 1867
182	ii.	Anna Hartshorn Anderson; born 1869.
183	iii.	Jessie Bannon Anderson; born 1871; died 1888.
184	iv.	Harry Manufull Anderson; born 1878; died 1879.
185	v.	Ethel Florine Anderson; born 1882.

82. JAMES⁵ PATRICK ANDERSON (Elizabeth⁴, Francis³, John², Unknown¹); born 1850; married 1877 HENRIETTA KNAUS.¹¹³⁴

Children of James and Henrietta (Knaus) Anderson:

186	i.	Edward⁶ Lawrence Anderson; born 1878; died 1894.
187	ii.	Frederick Anderson; born 1880.
188	iii.	Leroy Anderson; born 1883.

83. JOSEPH⁵ ADDISON ANDERSON (Elizabeth⁴, , Francis³, John², Unknown¹); born August 1853 in Pennsylvania; married in 1871 MARY ELIZABETH MCCULLOUGH, born February 1853; died 1912.¹¹³⁵

In 1900, and 1910, Joseph, Mary and family were living in Ellwood City, Lawrence County, Pennsylvania, where Joseph was enumerated as a janitor in 1900 (page 18A) and as a milk merchant in 1910 (page 4A). By 1920, Mary had died, but Joseph, widower, was still head of household with some of his adult children in Ellwood City (page 14A), where he was enumerated as a hardware clerk.

Children of Joseph and Mary (McCullough) Anderson (all born in Pennsylvania):

189	i.	James⁶ Hamilton Anderson; born April 1874. In 1900 and 1910, James H., single, was living with his parents in Ellwood City, Pennsylvania, where he was enumerated as a laborer in 1900 and as a tinner in 1910. In 1920, single, James was living with his father in Ellwood City. James probably did not marry.
190	ii.	Dudley Hannon Andererson; born 1875. I could not find Dudley in the federal censuses.
191	iii.	Franklin Reed Anderson; born 1878. I could not find Franklin in the federal censuses.
192	iv.	David McClure Anderson; born 1880. I could not find David in the federal censuses.
193	v.	Micah Irene Anderson; born November 1881. In 1900 Micah, single and living with her parents, was enumerated as a "salesman."
194	vi.	Tacie Florence Anderson; born June 1884. In 1910, Tacie was single and living with her parents; she was enumerated as a telephone operator.
195	vii.	Donald Parker Anderson; born December 1885. In 1910, Donald, single, was living with his parents; he was listed as a "layer-out" in a steel mill.
196	viii.	Joseph Russell Anderson; born May 1887; married Elresto [—?—]; born circa 1898 in Pennsylvania. In 1920. Russell and Elresto were living in Ellwood City, Ward 1, Lawrence County, Pennsylvankia (page 14A), in the household of Russell's father. Russell was enumerated as a clerk in an engine works in this census.
197	ix.	Myrtle Goldie Anderson; born April 1893. In 1920, Myrtle was still single and living with her father and brother Russell Anderson and Russell's wife in Ellwood City, Lawrence County, Pennsylvana; Myrtle was where listed as a school teacher in this census.

The Oil Creek McClintocks

and related families

Culbertsons

Generation Five